In its attempts to kill Verizon’s mega-spectrum deal with the cable operators, T-Mobile has opened up a new front in its lobbying war. The no. 4 U.S. operator is challenging Verizon’s claims that it is the most efficient user of mobile spectrum in the country. On Thursday, T-Mobile trotted out an expert to not only refute Verizon’s claims but show that Big Red is actually the most inefficient steward of the nation’s cellular airwaves.
Speaking at a T-Mobile media briefing, Illinois Institute of Technology Vice Provost and computer science research professor Dennis Roberson presented a study that accused Verizon of using flawed math when it made its efficiency calculations. He stated that once that math is corrected – surprise, surprise – T-Mobile comes out on top.
You can look at Roberson’s full regulatory filing and presentation on T-Mobile’s Website, but basically his argument is this: Verizon treats all of its connections as equals in its analysis without accounting for the number and usage levels of smartphones consuming most of the bandwidth; and Verizon treats all spectrum as equal though some frequencies are more efficient than others.
What it boils down to, though, is that Verizon is crunching its numbers one way, and T-Mobile is crunching them another way. I’m sure if he so chose, Roberson could finagle that data to correlate Verizon’s spectrum use to an increase in tooth decay.
The pathetic thing about this situation is that T-Mobile isn’t wrong. T-Mobile is the most efficient user of spectrum in the country, while Verizon is probably the most inefficient. T-Mobile’s argument is sitting right in front of it. Verizon is parked on loads of Advanced Wireless Service (AWS) and 700 MHz licenses that it has yet to touch and – in the case of 700 MHz – actually plans to sell. The Federal Communications has even started calling Verizon on its spectrum warehousing practices.
Meanwhile, T-Mobile has put practically every megahertz of spectrum its has every bought to use either in its GSM or HSPA+ networks. In fact, T-Mobile is so strapped for airwaves, it’s cannibalizing its 2G networks to make room for more efficient mobile broadband technologies such as LTE. T-Mobile couldn’t make a better argument than that to show it’s making the most of the limited resources it has.
T-Mobile is angling to get this deal killed so it can get a shot at buying up the cable operators’ penthouse airwaves. I have little doubt if T-Mobile were to prevail it would make immediate and good use of those frequencies, while its competitors might sit on them for several years.
But I also think T-Mobile is being a bit hypocritical here. T-Mobile today may be coming off as the consumer hero in magenta-colored tights, but a year ago things were very different. At the beginning of 2011, Deutsche Telekom had all but written off its U.S. operator, refusing to invest any more in spectrum or infrastructure. It threw in the towel completely when it agreed to sell T-Mobile USA to AT&T – which was perhaps the most anti-competitive action imaginable.
T-Mo has basically done a complete 180 in the space of a year, and now it’s asking the FCC to accommodate its new role as industry savior. It may be the everyman’s carrier today, and that’s great. But who knows what T-Mobile will be tomorrow.
Photo courtesy of Shutterstock user Picsfive
Related research and analysis from GigaOM Pro:
Subscriber content. Sign up for a free trial.
|Sat, May 18, 2013|
|03:00 PM||How cloud, big data and mobile will make the CMO the BMOC|
|01:30 PM||How to make Twitter the ultimate news ticker|
|12:00 PM||How iPads, apps and YouTube can be a band’s best practice tools|
|11:41 AM||Why Yahoo acquiring Tumblr for $1 billion makes a certain horrible kind of sense|
|11:00 AM||We’ve entered the age of emotional, design-centric, e-commerce|
|08:49 AM||Android this week: Google I/O recapped; Better Bluetooth; Galaxy S 4 Google Edition|
|03:00 AM||7 stories to read this weekend|
|Fri, May 17, 2013|
|08:25 PM||Report: Yahoo eager to close $1.1 billion cash deal for Tumblr by Sunday evening|
|07:30 PM||New networking features make hybrid clouds possible on Google Compute Engine|
|07:22 PM||Redbox Instant is coming to Google TV soon, Roku up next|
|06:59 PM||Tableau closes Day 1 as a $2.9B public company, up 64 percent|
|06:43 PM||With VentureHealth, InCube Ventures thinks crowdfunding can blend with traditional VCs|
|06:33 PM||Underwater batteries are making a splash for energy storage|
|05:37 PM||A sneak peek at YouTube’s future as it rolls out new channel design for everyone|
|05:24 PM||Database startup Drawn to Scale is closing down|
|05:20 PM||Crowdfunding a crack scandal — did Gawker go too far?|
|04:18 PM||Some of the best articles you need to read about Google I/O|
|03:46 PM||WebRTC is growing fast: soon to surpass one billion devices|
|03:44 PM||The future of Bitcoin: 3 predictions from experts|
|03:00 PM||Games for the weekend: Skylanders Cloud Patrol|
|02:37 PM||MOOCs aren’t the only kind of online course stirring debate on college campuses|
|02:29 PM||Surprise: Yahoo’s mobile push is working better than you think|
|02:06 PM||420,000 U.S. Cellular customers soon must make a choice: Join Sprint or find a new provider|
|12:56 PM||RapidShare lays off most of its staff as it struggles to find new business model|
|12:54 PM||Apple may not have answer for Google’s music service at WWDC|
|12:50 PM||Binge-watching forces “One Life to Live,” “All My Children” to cut back on new episodes|
|12:00 PM||Parakweet uses natural language processing to find value in your tweets|
|11:55 AM||Aruba buys indoor-location startup Meridian. Here’s why|
|11:15 AM||AWS is the McDonald’s of the cloud. Who’s the Burger King?|
|11:04 AM||Apple CEO will detail his corporate tax policy ideas to Congress next week|
|More Blogs From GigaOM|